Cover image for the article From Silence to a Gap Analysis, Part 4 of 4, by Mel K Meier, DBA, iB Consulting USA

From Silence to a Gap Analysis

Part 4 of 4. The series begins with The Skill of Reading the Silence in the Bylaws.

Across this series, a silence in the bylaws has been a sentence that reads one way to the people who wrote it and another way to the people who inherit it. What remains is what a silence can produce once it is found, and a discipline built for people under real conditions.

When a question turns personal

In the New York housing cooperative case from the first part, the pandemic had disrupted elections and the cooperative held a 2023 election for four of its seven seats, while two people took the view that every term had expired and that all seven seats belonged on the ballot. What followed was not a pause but an argument over what the bylaws required, settled later by an outside decision that let the election stand, as summarized by Giuseppe Chiara on the New York Commercial Division Blog, April 3, 2025. Research on work teams, a setting some distance from a boardroom, may suggest one reason the argument can come to matter more than the question that started it. Drawing on the distinction Jehn (1995) made between task conflict and relationship conflict, Yu and Wei (2025), in a meta-analysis of 32 longitudinal studies of teams, found that early disagreement about the task tended to be followed by later relationship conflict, the personal friction between people, while the reverse link was not significant. Scheppa-Lahyani and Zapf (2023), validating a measure built on Glasl’s (1982) stages of escalation, found that conflicts at later stages tended to carry more relationship conflict than conflicts at earlier ones. If a question about a bylaw turns personal, the agreements meant to carry an organization through a change of leaders can become harder to hold.

Human factors engineering and the bylaws

Human factors engineering is often described as a human centered approach to design, one that tends to start from how people behave under real conditions instead of from how they are supposed to behave. Writing about patient safety, Reason (2000) drew the line between two approaches. A person approach treats a lapse as something to correct in the individual, by naming the person or sending them for retraining. A system approach treats the same lapse as something to be expected, a consequence of conditions further upstream, and builds layered defenses so that one slip does not become a harm. His point was that the human condition cannot be changed, but the conditions under which people work can. Holden and Carayon (2021), describing a human factors framework used in health care, treat people, their tasks, their tools, and their surroundings as parts of one working system.

Bylaws can be seen as one of the tools inside a working system of that kind, and the same lens may apply. A provision that depends on everyone reading it in good faith may be a design that depends on vigilance. The tendencies described earlier in this series, which include reading through experience, self-serving bias, and motivated reasoning, may be better understood as part of the human condition, to be expected, than as something to correct in individual people. They can be as familiar as fatigue on a night shift, and governing documents written with them in mind can act as a layered defense, built so the organization holds on the day its people are at their most human. Much of that defense can sit in policy and procedure instead of in the bylaws themselves. That may be a kinder view of people than one that asks them to be better than most of us manage to be, and it is a view a board can take when it reads its own documents with those tendencies in mind.

A question to sit with is which sentence in your bylaws reads one way today and may read another way the morning after your next election, and who in your organization would be the first to notice.

This series

Related reading

If you would like an outside reading of your own documents, iB Consulting USA offers a Bylaw, Policy and Procedure Gap Analysis, an independent review of your governing documents against how your organization actually operates. An outside reader can bring what is hard to supply from inside, a past that is not yours. Send me a message.

Mel K Meier, DBA, helps boards, associations, leadership teams, and private equity sponsors see how an organization is governed and how it performs, leading to areas of opportunity to improve performance, clarity for decision making, and support for strategic planning. info@ibconsultingusa.com