Part 1 of 4.
Many of us have sat in a meeting where someone finally asks, “What do the bylaws actually say?” and someone goes looking, but the page doesn’t settle it. The line has been read aloud for years, and the people who used it thought they knew what it meant; now, with a new board at the table after an election, it can seem to mean something its authors may not have intended. The room goes quiet while people reread the same sentence, and although nothing about the words has changed, “who is reading them” has, because the people who wrote the line may no longer be the people who live under it.
What people call a loophole is often a silence, a situation the authors may not have pictured because they were standing inside the situation they knew best. A silence tends to matter most when it sits inside what can be called a self-judging clause, a provision that lets the people it applies to judge for themselves whether its conditions are met. The phrase is used in discussions of international trade, where a security exception in the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade allows a country to take action “which it considers necessary” to protect its essential security interests in listed circumstances. In 2019, a World Trade Organization panel found that the provision is not wholly self-judging, as Gerhard Erasmus summarized for tralac on July 11, 2019, a reminder that a provision can have more than one reader.
A bylaw can carry a similar shape without anyone intending it. When a provision says the board decides who is eligible, or that the board may fill a seat as it sees fit, the board can be both the subject of the rule and its reader, and whatever the board of the day honestly believes the words mean can become, in practice, what they mean. That may cause no difficulty while the people in the room agree. It can become one on the day a long-time reader and a fresh reader, each with a real stake in the organization, read the same sentence and need it to say different things. Reading those silences before the day they matter is a skill, and in my experience it can be learned by anyone willing to accept that a sentence can hold more than one truth. Each of us tends to read a rule through our own past experience, so two people of equal good faith can take the same words and arrive at different interpretations, and both can be honest. “The skill is reading your own documents through the experience of someone whose past is not yours.”
Why this matters to your board
Governance can be thought of as the backbone of an organization. It is made of the agreements about who holds authority, how a decision gets made and recorded, who may approve money and how much, who hires and evaluates the person who runs the place, how leaders are chosen and replaced, and what happens when people disagree. When one of those agreements carries a silence that has not been noticed yet, what may come first is not a pause but an argument over what the words were meant to cover. A housing cooperative in New York offers an example. After the pandemic disrupted its elections, it held an election in 2023 for four of its seven seats, describing the choice as a good faith effort to restore its staggered cycle and arguing that its bylaws did not govern how elections would run during the pandemic. Two people took the view that every term had expired and that all seven seats belonged on the ballot, and an outside decision later let the election stand, as summarized by Giuseppe Chiara on the New York Commercial Division Blog, April 3, 2025.
Whom is your organization governed for, the people in the room today, the people who will be in it after the next election, or both? Part 2 of this series, Bylaws Outlast the People Who Wrote Them, follows a silence from the day it is written.
This series
- Part 1 of 4. The Skill of Reading the Silence in the Bylaws (this article)
- Part 2 of 4. Bylaws Outlast the People Who Wrote Them
- Part 3 of 4. Why a Silent Bylaw Tends to Settle Toward Its Reader
- Part 4 of 4. From Silence to a Gap Analysis
Mel K Meier, DBA, helps boards, associations, leadership teams, and private equity sponsors see how an organization is governed and how it performs, leading to areas of opportunity to improve performance, clarity for decision making, and support for strategic planning. info@ibconsultingusa.com