Article cover: Culture Is a System, Not a Slogan by Mel K Meier, DBA, iB Consulting USA

Culture Is a System, Not a Slogan

Nearly every organization I have assessed had values on the wall. Integrity, excellence, teamwork, and others like them. In years of examining organizations, I found culture by watching three systems the wall does not often mention, more than by reading the wall itself.

How culture is taught

The first system is what gets rewarded, meaning what actually advances careers and earns raises. If collaboration is a stated value and promotions tend to go to internal competitors, the lived value can become competition, and employees often read that within their first few months. People are perceptive observers of their own workplaces.

Procedures teach the same lesson. An election rule may ask candidates who file by the deadline for a written statement while candidates nominated from the floor owe nothing, so following the rule asks more than skipping it. Nobody designed that incentive, and everyone approved the rule. The question a procedure raises is what it pays people to do.

What gets tolerated and what gets said

The second system is what gets tolerated. Many organizations carry working patterns they have learned to work around, often attached to contributions that are real and valued. Leaders who make those accommodations are often weighing a visible loss against a diffuse one, and the accommodation can become part of the actual standard, whether or not anyone intended it.

What gets talked about when things do not go as planned. The difference between a culture that asks who and a culture that asks what often takes shape in these moments. When the first question after a setback is “what happened,” people tend to bring setbacks forward early, and future decisions get made on a fuller picture.

From inside an organization, these lessons do not often feel like lessons. A new employee notices who is praised in a meeting, which deadlines are flexible for whom, and how a manager responds the first time a project slips. The lessons arrive without a briefing. People learn them the way thoughtful people learn any new place, by paying attention, and within a few months they know the real rules as well as anyone. That perceptiveness is a strength an organization can build on.

What the workforce learns unscheduled

Ten weeks into the job, a new employee I interviewed during an assessment could tell me which deadlines were flexible for whom and how her manager had responded the first time a project slipped. She had not been briefed on any of it. She had paid attention, the way thoughtful people do in any new place, and what she described was the culture as the three systems had taught it, with the values statement framed in the lobby a few steps away.

The distance between those two readings is itself a finding. The systems that taught her had each been built one decision at a time, for a sensible reason, by people who believed in the words on the wall. That is the part I find hopeful. Culture built by systems can be seen through systems, and an organization whose newest employee can describe the real rules already has a clear picture of what it teaches, before anyone thinks to teach it.

No two organizations are in the same position, so there is no single answer to hand you here. If something above matched what you are seeing on your own board or in your own department, the useful next step is a short conversation about your situation instead of a general answer.

Request a 15 minute conversation, call 402-230-7473, or write to info@ibconsultingusa.com.

Mel K Meier, DBA, leads iB Consulting USA, a woman owned, WOSB certified advisory firm and government contractor that works on public and private sector contracts. She serves boards, associations, and executive teams through board advisory, organizational diagnostics, portfolio company diagnostics for private equity sponsors, speaking engagements, and governance assessments. She helps boards, associations, leadership teams, and private equity sponsors see how an organization is governed and how it performs, leading to areas of opportunity to improve performance, clarity for decision making, and support for strategic planning.