Cover image for the article The Skill of Reading the Silence in the Bylaws by Mel K Meier, DBA, iB Consulting USA, board advisory and governance assessment

The Skill of Reading the Silence in the Bylaws

Many of us have sat in a meeting where someone finally asks, “What do the bylaws actually say?” and someone goes looking, but the page doesn’t settle it. The line has been read aloud for years, and the people who used it thought they knew what it meant; now, with a new board at the table after an election, it can seem to mean something its authors may not have intended. The room goes quiet while people reread the same sentence, and although nothing about the words has changed, “who is reading them” has, because the people who wrote the line may no longer be the people who live under it.

What people call a loophole is often a silence, a situation the authors may not have pictured because they were standing inside the situation they knew best. A silence tends to matter most when it sits inside what can be called a self-judging clause, a provision that lets the people it applies to judge for themselves whether its conditions are met. The phrase is used in discussions of international trade, for example about the security exception in the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade, which allows a country to take action “which it considers necessary” to protect its essential security interests in listed circumstances. In 2019, a World Trade Organization panel found that the provision is not wholly self-judging, as Gerhard Erasmus summarized for tralac on July 11, 2019, which is a reminder that a provision can have more than one reader.

A bylaw can carry a similar shape without anyone intending it. When a provision says the board decides who is eligible, or that the board may fill a seat as it sees fit, the board can be both the subject of the rule and its reader, and whatever the board of the day honestly believes the words mean can become, in practice, what they mean. That may cause no difficulty while the people in the room agree. It can become one on the day a long-time reader and a fresh reader, each with a real stake in the organization, read the same sentence and need it to say different things. Reading those silences before the day they matter is a skill, and in my experience it can be learned by anyone willing to accept that a sentence can hold more than one truth. Each of us tends to read a rule through our own past experience, so two people of equal good faith can take the same words and arrive at different interpretations, and both can be honest. “The skill is reading your own documents through the experience of someone whose past is not yours.”

Why this matters to your board

Governance can be thought of as the backbone of an organization. It is made of the agreements about who holds authority, how a decision gets made and recorded, who may approve money and how much, who hires and evaluates the person who runs the place, how leaders are chosen and replaced, and what happens when people disagree. Programs, hires, budgets, and plans tend to rest on those agreements being clear, and clear agreements can let staff act with confidence and help the organization plan past the term of the people currently in charge. When one of those agreements carries a silence that has not been noticed yet, what may come first is not a pause but an argument over what the words were meant to cover. A housing cooperative in New York offers an example. After the pandemic disrupted its elections, it held an election in 2023 for four of its seven seats, describing the choice as a good faith effort to restore its staggered cycle and arguing that its bylaws did not govern how elections would run during the pandemic. Two people took the view that every term had expired and that all seven seats belonged on the ballot, and an outside decision later let the election stand, as summarized by Giuseppe Chiara on the New York Commercial Division Blog, April 3, 2025.

Research on work teams, a setting some distance from a boardroom, may suggest one reason the argument can come to matter more than the question that started it. Drawing on the distinction Jehn (1995) made between task conflict and relationship conflict, Yu and Wei (2025), in a meta-analysis of 32 longitudinal studies of teams, found that early disagreement about the task tended to be followed by later relationship conflict, the personal friction between people, while the reverse link was not significant. Scheppa-Lahyani and Zapf (2023), validating a measure built on Glasl’s (1982) stages of escalation, found that conflicts at later stages tended to carry more relationship conflict than conflicts at earlier ones. If a question about a bylaw turns personal, the agreements meant to carry an organization through a change of leaders can become harder to hold, which is part of why reading the documents as others may read them can matter. Whom is your organization governed for, the people in the room today, the people who will be in it after the next election, or both?

How a silence gets written

A transition rule is often written in a calm season by people who care about the organization, and they write it from the vantage point of the group that holds authority now. From that chair, “the board” tends to mean the people at the table, so a sentence that names “the board” can read as complete. Future readers of the same sentence may have no seat at the table yet, which means the document can be thorough about what its authors can imagine and silent about something very likely to arrive, the day the work passes to the people who follow them. The people who may most need the rule are often the people who are not yet in the room to be consulted about it.

Diagram titled One question, two honest readings, a real case of a New York housing cooperative in 2023 whose elections were disrupted, with four of seven staggered seats on the ballot and two people reading all seven as open, by Mel K Meier, DBA, iB Consulting USA
A real case, a New York housing cooperative, 2023. Source, Giuseppe Chiara, New York Commercial Division Blog, April 3, 2025.

What it feels like from inside

Think about how a rule you have lived with actually reads to you. After enough years, you may not see the words anymore. You may see the meetings where it worked, the one time it was challenged, and the answer that seemed to settle it. So when someone reads the same line for the first time and says “that is not what it says,” the first feeling may not be curiosity but a small jolt, and under the jolt a sense that something you trusted has been questioned. That reader may feel something too, because they may see a sentence that seems to leave them out and wonder whether there is room for them in it.

Neither feeling is likely to be misplaced. Both people can be reading honestly from different places, and the document may have given them no way to notice that in advance. On paper, the organization can look fully governed, while to the people living through the transition the rules may seem to stop one step short of the door, and the distance between those two readings is often where the silence lives. If you have felt that distance, you may already understand more about governance than many documents can tell you.

Why people with competency miss it

This may have less to do with ability than with how a mind reads a rule it already knows. In my experience, the better you know a structure, the less visible your assumptions can become, until the words seem to carry the history instead of their meaning. Stenling et al. (2023), studying the nomination committees of 64 Swedish national sport organizations, found that those committees can shape a board before any election takes place, and an older case study by Pettigrew (1973) argued that the flow of information to a decision can shape what decision makers see. Both point to how much of what shapes a decision may sit outside the view of the people making it, without anyone intending that.

Self-serving bias and the reading of a rule

A well-studied pattern may help explain why a silent sentence tends to settle toward the reader. Self-serving bias, in the sense most relevant here, is the tendency to judge what is fair, and to weigh ambiguous information, in the direction that suits us, and it may operate in people of ordinary honesty without their noticing. Babcock and Loewenstein (1997), reviewing their studies of negotiation, found that people tended to judge fairness in their own favor by evaluating information selectively, and that this bias contributed to impasse. Coutts et al. (2024) found a related pattern in experiments where feedback mixed a person’s own contribution with a teammate’s, as people updated their beliefs about their own ability in a self-serving direction, which did not happen when the other influence on the result was random. It seems reasonable to think a bylaw at a transition may share some of that shape. When the words leave room and the readers have something at stake, the reading that favors the reader can arrive feeling like the obvious meaning of the text. That may be why it can be hard to see from inside.

Good faith and design

Once a silence is noticed, a board may decide to leave it alone because the people in the room trust one another, and that trust is often well placed. It may have one limit. Inside the room, a self-judging rule tends to restrain the majority only when the majority consents to be restrained. One difference between good faith and a written rule can be timing. Good faith tends to be tested after a decision has produced its result, while a written rule tends to do its work earlier, at the moment the question is asked.

There may be a reason that limit is easy to overlook. In my experience, people who read a silent clause in their own favor may not experience it that way. In a related finding, Christensen and Moynihan (2024) reported that when local elected officials in Denmark were asked to justify a judgment, they leaned more on their prior views and less on the data, while among members of the public the evidence pointed weakly the other way. The pattern fits what Kunda (1990) described as motivated reasoning, and it seems to attach to the seat more than to the person. A board is not a city council, but a seat at the table may carry a similar pull toward a familiar reading. My research with athletic administrators (Meier, 2025, 2026) looks at decisions made with limited time, incomplete information, and real consequences, and draws on the limits on rational choice that Simon (1955) described and on how people weigh a loss against a gain, which Kahneman and Tversky (1979) mapped and Ruggeri et al. (2020) replicated across 19 countries. Belli et al. (2024), in a meta-analysis of 213 effects reported in 83 papers, found that time pressure can raise or lower risk taking depending on the conditions of the decision, a question Ordóñez and Benson (1997) studied in earlier experiments on time pressure and risky choice. Those studies looked at risky choices and not at the reading of a rule, so the most that seems reasonable to say is that pressure may change how a rule gets read too, in ways that are hard to predict. That may be why a clearly written document, kept to by consent, can hold where sincerity alone may not.

What bylaws are for

Bylaws do not govern by magic so much as by consent, and an organization tends to stay fair largely because the majority of the moment agrees, voluntarily, to play by the rules it inherited, which may be why keeping to the bylaws matters most when keeping to them is inconvenient. That may be the moment they are doing their work.

Human factors engineering and the bylaws

There is a discipline that has worked for many years on a closely related question, which is how to build systems that hold when the people inside them are being people. Human factors engineering is often described as a human centered approach to design, one that tends to start from how people behave under real conditions, with the shortcuts, the fatigue, the biases, and the time pressure left in, instead of from how they are supposed to behave. Writing about patient safety, Reason (2000) drew the line between two approaches. A person approach treats a lapse as something to correct in the individual, by naming the person or sending them for retraining. A system approach treats the same lapse as something to be expected, a consequence of conditions further upstream, and builds layered defenses so that one slip does not become a harm. His point was that the human condition cannot be changed, but the conditions under which people work can. Holden and Carayon (2021), describing a human factors framework used in health care, treat people, their tasks, their tools, and their surroundings as parts of one working system, and one of its mapping exercises shows how people relate in practice instead of how an organization chart draws them.

Bylaws can be seen as one of the tools inside a working system of that kind, and the same lens may apply. A provision that depends on everyone reading it in good faith may be a design that depends on vigilance. Consent may keep people playing by the rules, while clear words may help them agree on what the rules say. The tendencies described above, which include reading through experience, self-serving bias, and motivated reasoning, may be better understood as part of the human condition, to be expected, than as something to correct in individual people. They can be as familiar as fatigue on a night shift, and governing documents written with them in mind can act as a layered defense, built so the organization holds on the day its people are at their most human. Much of that defense can sit in policy and procedure instead of in the bylaws themselves. That may be a kinder view of people than one that asks them to be better than most of us manage to be, and it is a view a board can take when it reads its own documents with those tendencies in mind.

In my view, bylaws exist for the moment when the people change, and the organization still needs to go on being itself. They can work as a promise made by one board to boards it may not meet, so a bylaw may need to outlast the people who wrote it, the people reading it today, and the people who read it next, and mean the same thing to all three. A rule that works while its authors are in the room, and not after, can start to behave like a habit, and habits tend to leave with the people who hold them.

Where change belongs

None of this is a case for rewriting the bylaws each time a question comes up, and in my experience the bylaws tend to work best as the last place to change, not the first. Much of what arises in a season may live at the level of policy and procedure, and that is where it can usually be resolved without touching the document that is meant to outlast the people in the room. A bylaw change can reach further than its authors can see, for the same reason the original silence did. A proposal to change the bylaws deserves the highest scrutiny the organization can offer, from readers whose past differs from that of its authors, with the question asked of what the change would mean to a board that does not exist yet. That scrutiny can be another use of the skill of reading the silence.

A question to sit with is which sentence in your bylaws reads one way today and may read another way the morning after your next election, and who in your organization would be the first to notice.

Related reading

If you would like an outside reading of your own documents, iB Consulting USA offers a Bylaw, Policy and Procedure Gap Analysis, an independent review of your governing documents against how your organization actually operates. An outside reader can bring what is hard to supply from inside, a past that is not yours. Send me a message.

Mel K Meier, DBA, helps boards, associations, leadership teams, and private equity sponsors see how an organization is governed and how it performs, leading to areas of opportunity to improve performance, clarity for decision making, and support for strategic planning. info@ibconsultingusa.com