Cover image for the article Bylaws Outlast the People Who Wrote Them, Part 2 of 4, by Mel K Meier, DBA, iB Consulting USA

Bylaws Outlast the People Who Wrote Them

Part 2 of 4. The series begins with The Skill of Reading the Silence in the Bylaws.

Part 1 looked at the silence a self-judging clause can carry, where the board a rule applies to is also the board that decides what it means. Time can add to that silence, because a bylaw can have a longer life than any board.

How a silence gets written

A transition rule is often written in a calm season by people who care about the organization, and they write it from the vantage point of the group that holds authority now. From that chair, “the board” tends to mean the people at the table, so a sentence that names “the board” can read as complete. Future readers of the same sentence may have no seat at the table yet, which means the document can be thorough about what its authors can imagine and silent about something very likely to arrive, the day the work passes to the people who follow them. The people who may most need the rule are often the people who are not yet in the room to be consulted about it.

What it feels like from inside

Think about how a rule you have lived with actually reads to you. After enough years, you may not see the words anymore. You may see the meetings where it worked, the one time it was challenged, and the answer that seemed to settle it. So when someone reads the same line for the first time and says “that is not what it says,” the first feeling may not be curiosity but a small jolt, and under the jolt a sense that something you trusted has been questioned. That reader may feel something too, because they may see a sentence that seems to leave them out and wonder whether there is room for them in it.

Neither feeling is likely to be misplaced. Both people can be reading honestly from different places, and the document may have given them no way to notice that in advance. The distance between those two readings is often where the silence lives. If you have felt that distance, you may already understand more about governance than many documents can tell you.

What bylaws are for

Bylaws do not govern by magic so much as by consent, and an organization tends to stay fair largely because the majority of the moment agrees, voluntarily, to play by the rules it inherited, which may be why keeping to the bylaws matters most when keeping to them is inconvenient. That may be the moment they are doing their work.

In my view, bylaws exist for the moment when the people change, and the organization still needs to go on being itself. They can work as a promise made by one board to boards it may not meet, so a bylaw may need to outlast the people who wrote it, the people reading it today, and the people who read it next, and mean the same thing to all three. A rule that works while its authors are in the room, and not after, can start to behave like a habit, and habits tend to leave with the people who hold them.

Where change belongs

None of this is a case for rewriting the bylaws each time a question comes up, and in my experience the bylaws tend to work best as the last place to change, not the first. Much of what arises in a season may live at the level of policy and procedure, and that is where it can usually be resolved without touching the document that is meant to outlast the people in the room. A bylaw change can reach further than its authors can see, for the same reason the original silence did. A proposal to change the bylaws deserves the highest scrutiny the organization can offer, from readers whose past differs from that of its authors, with the question asked of what the change would mean to a board that does not exist yet.

Which rule in your bylaws works today because its authors are still in the room, and what would it say to the people who follow them? Part 3 of this series, Why a Silent Bylaw Tends to Settle Toward Its Reader, looks at the person doing the reading.

This series

Mel K Meier, DBA, helps boards, associations, leadership teams, and private equity sponsors see how an organization is governed and how it performs, leading to areas of opportunity to improve performance, clarity for decision making, and support for strategic planning. info@ibconsultingusa.com