Part 3 of 4. The series begins with The Skill of Reading the Silence in the Bylaws.
Part 1 and Part 2 looked at the silence a bylaw can carry, the situation its authors may not have pictured, and at why a bylaw may need to outlast the people who wrote it. That leaves the person doing the reading.
Why people with competency miss it
In my experience, the better you know a structure, the less visible your assumptions can become, until the words seem to carry the history instead of their meaning. Stenling et al. (2023), studying the nomination committees of 64 Swedish national sport organizations, found that those committees can shape a board before any election takes place, and an older case study by Pettigrew (1973) argued that the flow of information to a decision can shape what decision makers see. Both point to how much of what shapes a decision may sit outside the view of the people making it.
Self-serving bias and the reading of a rule
A well-studied pattern may help explain why a silent sentence tends to settle toward the reader. Self-serving bias, in the sense most relevant here, is the tendency to judge what is fair, and to weigh ambiguous information, in the direction that suits us, and it may operate in people of ordinary honesty without their noticing. Babcock and Loewenstein (1997), reviewing their studies of negotiation, found that people tended to judge fairness in their own favor by evaluating information selectively, and that this bias contributed to impasse. Coutts et al. (2024) found a related pattern in experiments where feedback mixed a person’s own contribution with a teammate’s, as people updated their beliefs about their own ability in a self-serving direction, which did not happen when the other influence on the result was random. It seems reasonable to think a bylaw at a transition may share some of that shape. When the words leave room and the readers have something at stake, the reading that favors the reader can arrive feeling like the obvious meaning of the text.
Good faith and design
Once a silence is noticed, a board may decide to leave it alone because the people in the room trust one another, and that trust is often well placed. It may have one limit. Inside the room, a self-judging rule, one that lets the people it applies to judge for themselves whether its conditions are met, tends to restrain the majority only when the majority consents to be restrained. One difference between good faith and a written rule can be timing. Good faith tends to be tested after a decision has produced its result, while a written rule tends to do its work earlier, at the moment the question is asked.
In my experience, people who read a silent clause in their own favor may not experience it that way. Christensen and Moynihan (2024) reported that when local elected officials in Denmark were asked to justify a judgment, they leaned more on their prior views and less on the data, while among members of the public the evidence pointed weakly the other way. The pattern fits what Kunda (1990) described as motivated reasoning, and it seems to attach to the seat more than to the person. A board is not a city council, but a seat at the table may carry a similar pull toward a familiar reading. My research with athletic administrators (Meier, 2025, 2026) looks at decisions made with limited time, incomplete information, and real consequences, and draws on the limits on rational choice that Simon (1955) described and on how people weigh a loss against a gain, which Kahneman and Tversky (1979) mapped and Ruggeri et al. (2020) replicated across 19 countries. That work looked at choices and not at the reading of a rule, so the most that seems reasonable to say is that the way a person weighs a loss against a gain may shape how a rule gets read too. That may be why a clearly written document, kept to by consent, can hold where sincerity alone may not.
If a reading can settle toward the reader without anyone noticing, what would it take for your board to notice? Part 4 of this series, From Silence to a Gap Analysis, asks how governing documents can be written for the people who will read them.
This series
- Part 1 of 4. The Skill of Reading the Silence in the Bylaws
- Part 2 of 4. Bylaws Outlast the People Who Wrote Them
- Part 3 of 4. Why a Silent Bylaw Tends to Settle Toward Its Reader (this article)
- Part 4 of 4. From Silence to a Gap Analysis
Mel K Meier, DBA, helps boards, associations, leadership teams, and private equity sponsors see how an organization is governed and how it performs, leading to areas of opportunity to improve performance, clarity for decision making, and support for strategic planning. info@ibconsultingusa.com